The Phenom (2016)
Rent The Phenom on Amazon Video
Written by: Noah Buschel
Directed by: Noah Buschel
Starring: Ethan Hawke, Paul Giamatti, Johnny Simmons
Rated: --/R
Plot:
An unorthodox sports psychologist helps a talented major league rookie pitcher who suddenly can't find the strike zone.
Verdict:
Really
great acting from all three head liners, intimate directing, but an
ending that will leave you feeling like something is missing. It tells a
story about a talented athlete and a turbulent home life that warped
his mind. Just as the conclusion is building, the movie ends. I
appreciate that it bucks the trend of the Hollywood ending, but the
preceding scene could have set up the ending and it doesn't. The
omission of an ending doesn't detract from the story this tells, but
this is just strange enough that it's going to alienate people.
It depends.
Review:
At first glance this looks like serious version of Kevin Costner's Bull Durham (1988) or Brendan Frasier's The Scout (1994) with a therapist instead of a grizzled veteran catcher and scout/agent respectively.
This
jumps right into the movie without even a production company logo, with
the therapist (Giamatti) and Hopper Gibson (Simmons) in a session. It's
a great opening scene, inexplicably followed by ae title sequence set
against a horrid floral print pattern.
I wondered how
much actual baseball would be in this, and there isn't much. We get a
couple of scenes where Hopper pitches and that's it. At least the movie
gets its references correct with Nolan Ryan and Walter Johnson.
It
even gets into the NCAA and the money it makes off of players. One
character proposes getting rid of the draft, which is crazy. The movie
uses this to show that Hopper just plays the game, he doesn't care about
politics, but to address no draft, big market teams would sign most of
the talent. The draft is for parity and competitive play.
The
timeline bounces around from the therapist to Hopper's failure during a
big league game to being scouted in high school. It's trying to create a
stream of consciousness feel. It spends a lot of time at high school,
more than I expected. I wondered if it was going to create a comparison
of his life before being drafted, right after, and then now that his
career is potentially in shambles. It doesn't do that. We see his life
before the draft and then after he lost command of his pitches. We don't
know what happened in the minors, but Hopper was successful in the
major until he lost the ability to throw strikes.
We
know he plays for Atlanta. The movie never mentions the club name. We
later see him rehabbing and wearing a Gwinnet Bulls jersey. Gwinnett is a
double A farm team in Georgia for Atlanta, though the movie claims the
Bulls are in California.
Simmons does an amazing job as
the movie explores living in the shadow of a father despite possessing
more talent. This is a teen struggling with unfathomable pressure
masquerading as a baseball movie. Hopper could have any insanely high
paying profession and the arc could play out the same way. Baseball does
make sense as there is a precedent of professionals losing the ability
to throw strikes or to first base (Mark Wohlers, Chuck Knoblauch). This is often called the 'yips' and that is mentioned. Howard Glass as referenced in the film is not real.
Ethan
Hawke's as Hopper's dad is a real piece of work, as advertised. It's
not often you hate a character so completely so quickly. In a few
minutes after returning, he throws a beer can at his son. I find it
doubtful that he wouldn't have been arrested for abuse.
This
character threw his life away and is living through his son. He takes
out his disappointment and frustration on his son, but also wants to
take all the credit forHopper's success.
Buschel takes a
very gentle look at Hopper. I don't know how else to describe the
directing. This is a character study about an extremely talented kid and
his turbulent home life. His dad warped him. The direction is
impressive from holding shots, to the focus, and the editing. Some
scenes are almost edited to misdirect, but it's so small that you could
almost miss it.
One of the best scenes is in the therapist's
office as Hopper considers what he really wants in life and admits his
team signed the wrong guy. It's a great scene that's directed and acted
very well.
The ending is going to annoy a lot of
people. It feels like it's building to an emotional payoff, something
the movie has been building since the first scene. In the middle of the
scene it just cuts to black. Where is the rest of the movie? I had to
make sure the DVD didn't freeze and that something didn't go wrong. It
ended in mid scene.
I'm left searching for the ending. I
get enough to make some guesses about how this concludes, but I'm still
at a loss. In essence Hopper had to face his dad one last time. It was a
chance for them both to open up, which is completely uncharacteristic.
The movie could have set this up better with the therapist laying out
what Hopper needs to do and let us know this is part of the road to
recovery. We can glean that, but still the final scene stop almost in
mid sentence.
Sunday, October 9, 2016
Subscribe to:
Post Comments
(
Atom
)
No comments :
Post a Comment